Two bug-hunt findings that were doc inaccuracies, not code bugs:
- Tab title "(N)" is the mention/highlight count (+ "·" for other unread),
mirroring the favicon — intentional. LOTUS_FEATURES said "N unread messages";
corrected to describe the actual highlight-count behavior.
- Collapsible long messages use a fixed COLLAPSE_MAX_HEIGHT (320px ≈ 20 lines);
the doc claimed a Settings → Appearance control that never existed. Corrected
to describe the fixed threshold rather than build a marginal per-user setting.
Verified against ClientNonUIFeatures.tsx and MsgTypeRenderers.tsx.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Closes the avatar-decoration cluster (live-update pub/sub, CDN-override
thumbnail, profile-404), the DND badge color, and the DenoiseTester
model-node leak + async mounted-guard — commits 29ff1654 and c9d9d914.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Records the 3-agent + live-infra investigation into moving MatrixRTC call
membership to sticky events. Conclusion: enabling msc4354_enabled on Synapse
is low-risk/reversible but a no-op by itself (EC stays in Legacy mode behind a
per-device dev toggle; fleet is single-hosted so upgrades atomically). The one
unverified risk is media-layer interop (lk-jwt /get_token vs /sfu/get resolving
to the same LiveKit room) — needs a two-account cross-mode test before any
default change. Parked as a scoped future rollout, not a flag flip.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
- Mark the desktop Tauri CSP frame-src finding FIXED (cinny-desktop daba59b).
- Add the GIF-animation fix + Mixcloud/Deezer embeds write-up (4154cae5),
incl. the Deezer /show vs /podcast correction.
- New section: Matrix 2.0 call membership (MSC4354 sticky events) —
investigated across 3 agents, deliberately NOT enabled. Records why the
server flag is a no-op alone (EC gates it behind a per-device developer
setting defaulting to Legacy), what was verified safe, and the one open
risk (lk-jwt-service LiveKit-alias mapping across the two JWT endpoints)
that a two-account test call must settle before any rollout.
- Refresh Server Capabilities: Synapse 1.157.1, MSC list re-dumped live from
/_matrix/client/versions, note that msc4143 is not a real gap (LiveKit is
discovered via .well-known) and that msc3861 client code is now dead.
- Note the blocked-feature re-check found no change on 1.157.1.
- Drop a verbatim-duplicated "remaining providers" heading; provider count
16 -> 18.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Per-slice hunt over the LOTUS_FEATURES surface (theming / calls / messaging /
threads-presence-UX / rooms-mod-notif-infra-desktop), verified against current
code. Records ~20 residual findings (desktop-CSP missing Steam/Mixcloud/Deezer
frame-src hosts; DenoiseTester model-node leak; PiP auto-spotlight not released;
avatar-decoration no live update; DND badge shown as Idle; toast overflow;
Focus-Assist mount hydration; + Low tail).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Fixes the prettier CI gate that failed on bc608b37 — check:prettier runs
`prettier --check .` over the whole repo (incl. markdown), and prettier's
markdown style uses `_italic_`. Prior doc commits slipped `*italic*` through
because I only ran prettier on changed src files, not the .md.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Test-coverage batch 2 (2-agent reviewed, both SHIP; isolation verified — Node
runs each test file in its own process, so the console patch can't leak).
- cryptoDiagLog.test.ts: the E2EE KE-cluster diagnostics tool — KE-signature
capture vs ignore, most-specific-first match order, KE-3/KE-4 rows, Error /
object / circular-arg serialization (String() fallback never throws), the
200-entry ring-buffer eviction, getCryptoDiagEntries copy semantics,
install idempotency, and buildCryptoDiagReport's client metadata + LOCKED
PII-safe key set (no field can silently leak) + no-client/throwing-getter
fallbacks. Silences console pass-through so the ring-buffer test stays quiet.
- closedLobbyCategories.test.ts: mirrors closedNavCategories — id join,
hydrate, PUT/DELETE, idempotent PUT, no-op DELETE, array persistence,
per-user key namespacing.
Also: mark the EC in-call mobile UI audit done in LOTUS_TODO (stale entry;
shipped as element-call:lotus e36aef8a).
Gates: tsc 0, eslint 0, prettier clean, 911 tests, build ok.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Mark the code-level mobile responsive audit done (M1-M6 + N1-N2 shipped) and
list what remains: runtime device QA, the Element Call fork in-call mobile UI,
M2/iOS touch discoverability, the sub-44px sweep, avatar-decoration reduced-
motion, and the Twitch/Twitter/TikTok card restructuring.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Replace the open Discovery-pass-2 list with a completion summary + commit refs
(PERF-1..5, SEC-1..4, COR-1..6 shipped this session, gate-green, each reviewed
by two agents). Record PERF-6 / SEC-5 as deferred-informational and note KE-1's
storage.persist() preventive is already implemented.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
check:prettier was not part of my gate routine, so formatting drift accumulated
across the session's touched files (and a few older ones). Run prettier --write
to bring the repo back to 'All matched files use Prettier code style!'.
Formatting only — no logic changes. tsc/tests/build all green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Three agents swept fresh lenses (performance, security/privacy, correctness in
under-covered subsystems). 16 verified items filed: PERF-1..6, SEC-1..5 (no
exploitable XSS found — sanitization surface is hardened), COR-1..6. Single-pass,
not yet TPVR'd.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The discovery-pass items DP1-DP18 are implemented + TPVR-reviewed, so move their
manual QA steps into LOTUS_TESTING.md (new section R) and replace the DP backlog
block in LOTUS_TODO.md with a done-breadcrumb pointing at §R + the commits.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Three discovery agents swept src/ for correctness/a11y/tech-debt issues beyond the
tracked backlog; a separate TPVR pass independently confirmed all 18 (5 refined to
partial with count/scope corrections). Filed as DP1-DP18 under Open - Actionable.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Room preview (JoinBeforeNavigate -> RoomCard via getRoomSummary) was already
built and, verified after the Synapse 1.156 upgrade, works via the SDK's unstable
im.nheko.summary endpoint (the old 'blocked' flag tested the wrong /v1 path).
Polish the preview card with the summary fields the endpoint returns:
- join-rule chip (Restricted / Ask to join / Invite only / Private; public shows
none) + an Encrypted badge (from im.nheko.summary.encryption).
- knock-rule rooms now show a 'Request to join' button (mx.knockRoom) instead of a
plain Join that would fail — mirrors the RoomIntro knock flow.
Props are optional so other RoomCard usages are unaffected. LOTUS_TODO updated:
Room Preview BLOCKED -> done; Synapse 1.155 -> 1.156.0. 738 tests pass.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Editor (SoundboardPackEditor): show each clip's length in seconds (stored on
upload via getAudioDurationMs, and captured on preview for existing clips); the
preview button now toggles play/stop with a 'now playing' equalizer indicator;
reworked the volume control into a fixed cell with a % readout so the slider's
max no longer collides with the delete button.
Call soundboard: clip names wrap (up to 3 lines, word-break) instead of being
truncated with an ellipsis; cards grow to fit.
TODO: logged the basic audio-editor / video->audio-extractor as a large project.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
handleReceipt recomputed unread from getUnreadNotificationCount, which is
server-computed and stale on the synchronous synthetic receipt echo (the SDK
only zeroes it immediately when the last event is our own message). Reading
someone else's message therefore PUT the stale non-zero count back -> dot stuck
or resurrected on the ack-sync ordering race. Restore upstream cinny's
optimistic DELETE on our own receipt; the UnreadNotifications listener re-asserts
the accurate badge on the server ack.
Also collapse a {total:0,highlight:0} PUT to a DELETE in the reducer (a present
map entry lights the dot via hasUnread=!!unread, so phantom {0,0} PUTs from the
UnreadNotifications listener left stuck dots).
Mark-as-Unread (MSC2867): clear the flag directly in markAsRead (opening an
already-read room sends no receipt, so the receipt-driven auto-clear never
fired), and gate the receipt auto-clear to main/unthreaded receipts so reading
one thread no longer wipes the whole-room flag.
Tests: 700/700 pass; typecheck + prod build clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Full-surface protocol survey. Flags each remaining gap by what unblocks it:
buildable now (custom room tags/sections — the only substantive client-only one
left), needs infra (email/3PID invites → identity server; MSC4108/3814), and
blocked-until-Synapse-upgrade (live location 3489/3672, reaction redaction 3892,
room preview 3266, thread subs 4306). Space reordering already works (drag) — not
a gap. Corrected per user.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Three research passes concluded ~10% confidence a full rollout wouldn't
break/regress (js-sdk SlidingSync is _internal_/experimental + labs-only at
Element, presence not delivered over sliding sync, no upstream Cinny reference,
and Cinny's nav is built from the full local room set — ~14 subsystems assume
completeness). Server side is GA. Parked; revisit on Rust SDK adoption or large
accounts. Full assessment in the plan history.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Phase C.1 of the protocol-gaps roadmap, gate-green (693 tests). Generalizes the
Element Call widget host into a general room-widget feature:
- StateEvent.Widget + widgetsPanelAtom + useRoomWidgets (WidgetParser).
- RoomWidgetView: sandboxed-iframe host via ClientWidgetApi with a conservative
GeneralWidgetDriver (approves only benign display caps — no room-event
send/read/to-device). Blocks same-origin widget URLs (sandbox breakout guard).
- WidgetsPanel: list / open / add / remove, PL-gated on im.vector.modular.widgets,
https + non-same-origin URL validation. Mounted like the media gallery (header
toggle + 3-way content-panel exclusivity + mobile full-screen overlay).
- Tested URL/capability/id helpers.
Requires the prod CSP frame-src widening (matrix repo) for external widgets.
v1 cuts (capability consent prompt, Jitsi/sticker types, user widgets) noted.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
B2 of the Matrix protocol-gaps roadmap, gate-green (688 tests):
- Enable QR verification methods (show/scan/reciprocate) in initMatrix.
- Extend DeviceVerification: the Ready step offers your own QR (byte-mode encode
via qrcode), a camera 'Scan their QR code' flow, and an emoji fallback; the
Started step routes reciprocate → a confirm step (useVerifierShowReciprocateQr)
or SAS as before.
- New QrScanner component: getUserMedia + jsQR, handing the raw binaryData bytes
to request.scanQRCode (BarcodeDetector is string-only, so can't be used).
- Adds qrcode + jsqr (small, pure-JS, client-only); build-verified under rolldown.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Two Matrix protocol gaps (Phase A), gate-green (683 tests):
- Mark as Unread: m.marked_unread room account data (+ com.famedly.marked_unread
fallback), a new markedUnreadAtom binder that seeds from account data and
clears on our own read receipt (MSC2867). RoomNavItem gains Mark as Unread /
Read menu items and lights the row dot for a marked room. Tested.
- Low Priority: m.lowpriority room tag mirroring favourites — a context-menu
toggle (mutually exclusive with Favorite) and a collapsed Low Priority
category sorted to the bottom of the Home room list.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Six confirmed client-buildable gaps + server-gated items from a spec/MSC audit:
Mark as Unread (MSC2867), Low Priority rooms (m.lowpriority), Disappearing
Messages (MSC1763), QR Device Verification, Room Widgets (MSC1236), Sliding Sync
(MSC3575/4186). Phased build order.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Removed resolved audit-wave finding tables and shipped-feature narratives (now
in LOTUS_FEATURES.md + git history); kept every open/blocked/deferred item, the
E2EE + Web Push backlog, and the reference tables (server caps, key files, EC
fork ops, CI/CD).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Clears the clean 🟡 remainders from the feature audit (gate-green, 677 tests):
- F3: getFallbackSession prefers the session-blob/legacy source with the later
expiresAt (a downgrade→upgrade could boot on a stale blob's dead token).
- F6: server-forced logout (SessionLoggedOut) now mirrors logoutClient —
pushSessionToSW() + best-effort revokeOidcTokens for OIDC sessions (the search
plaintext wipe was already added).
- N5: deleteUnreadInfo parent fallback `?? roomId` → `?? []` (latently spread the
roomId string into chars).
- P10: useUserPresence re-seeds when the User object appears after first render.
- forward: strip m.mentions so forwarding doesn't re-ping the original mentions.
Left open: F5 (OIDC expiry not reachable in persistTokens), N6/H10/D7 (minor /
runtime-verify). See LOTUS_TODO.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Wave-3 bug-hunt fixes (findings in LOTUS_TODO), reviewed + gate-green:
- 🔴 ACL editor [H1–H4]: block saving an empty allow-list (was a one-click
federation brick), warn on self-ban (case-insensitive glob match of
mx.getDomain() vs allow/deny), accept real globs (1.2.3.*, *.evil.*), and
gate Save behind a confirm dialog.
- 🔴 [P1] room context menu no longer acts on the wrong room after a live
reorder (key by roomId, not list index). 🔴 [P2] status writes no longer
force presence to online over Invisible/DND (shared presenceStateFromSetting).
- 🟠 [P3] timed mutes restored on boot; [P4] custom-status auto-clear now fires
(always-mounted StatusExpiryMonitor); [P5] timezone also PUT to the m.tz
profile field so it's visible to others; [H6] RoomInsights single-pass
min/max (was Math.min(...spread) stack overflow); [H7/H8] mod-log labels.
- 🟡 [P6/P7] favorites collapse+filter, [P8] charCount reset, [P9] DM preview
refresh on decrypt; theming [T-P1] lazy decorations, [T-P2] drop the redundant
always-on body animation, [T-P4] live useReducedMotion, [T-P5] decoration key.
- NATIVE-CINNY LAW: notification presets + Powers permissions use folds icons.
DEFERRED: [H5] invite-QR is fetched from api.qrserver.com (third-party leak);
local generation needs a bundled QR lib (not added). tsc/eslint/prettier clean,
build OK, 677 tests.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
- Notification profile presets (P5-27) used literal emoji (🎮/💼/🌙) instead of
folds Icons → Gaming=Ball, Work=Monitor, Sleep=BellMute.
- Permissions "Powers" list used ✅/❌ text emoji for has/no-power → folds
Icons.Check / Icons.Cross (colored via the row).
Reviewed the rest of the UI: seasonal-theme picker emoji kept (folds has no
holiday-icon equivalents; a distinctly-Lotus visual feature), soundboard clip
emoji kept (user-chosen clip identity), URL-preview brand glyphs + upstream
device-verification emoji + keyboard key-symbols left as-is.
(Also records the F2 URL-preview decision: keep default-on.)
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Web fixes from the Wave-2 bug-hunt (findings in LOTUS_TODO):
- F1 (security): wipe the decrypted-plaintext search index on SERVER-FORCED
logout too (token expiry / remote sign-out) — only manual logout did before.
F4: the delete no longer reports success while onblocked (waits, 3s cap).
- M1/M2 (data-loss): useBookmarks + useUserNotes account-data writes are now
serialized at MODULE scope (single queue + latestRef per client, echo-driven),
fixing the cross-instance lost-update clobber (useBookmarks mounts per message
row, so a per-instance queue was insufficient — caught in review).
- M6: room-history export gets a 200-page cap + Cancel + unmount-abort +
correct date-range early-break (raw paginated ts). M4: image compression
skips PNG (was flattening transparency to black), bakes EXIF orientation via
createImageBitmap, .jpg-renames, and falls back to the original on decode
failure instead of dropping the file. M5: MediaGallery lightbox opens the
right item (shared thumb guard). M8: audio speed survives async decrypt.
- Desktop web wiring: D2 badge sums leaf rooms only (space double-count, like
the favicon fix); D3 useTauriDnd re-hydrates from get_tray_dnd on mount; D5
updater has a terminal state.
Reviewed; M7 reverted (past-time clamp is an intentional, tested contract).
tsc/eslint/prettier clean, build OK, 678 tests.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
- C-H1: forceState only on FIRST join; on EC reconnect re-arm the fork handlers
(resendForkState — deafen+quality only) instead of clobbering live mic/video/
deafen back to the join-time snapshot.
- C-H2: AFK auto-mute reads the fork's io.lotus.call_state VAD of the LOCAL
published track instead of getUserMedia on the browser DEFAULT mic (which could
measure silence while the user spoke on another device → auto-mute an active
speaker). Fails safe (never mutes) when call_state is null OR empty.
- C-H3: control observer re-binds after EC re-renders (body subtree:true + 100ms
debounce) with an early-return so unchanged state doesn't re-render.
- C-M3 setQuality join-gated; C-M4 hangup 4s fallback dispose (idempotent);
C-M5 PTT no longer silently un-deafens; C-M6 screenshare-audio mute resets on
stop; C-L4 deafen key works in the iframe; C-L6 setState-after-unmount guards.
Reviewed (C-H2 [] fail-safe + C-H3 re-render guard applied). tsc/eslint/prettier
clean, build OK, 677 tests.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
- T1 (🔴): markThreadAsRead no longer receipts the thread ROOT (a 2nd instance
of the read-marker-corruption regression — opening a thread whose root is old
re-lit the whole room). Extracted to a pure threadReceipt.ts + 5 regression
tests.
- N1 (🔴): favicon/tab-title unread count now sums only leaf rooms (was double-
counting every ancestor-space aggregate in roomToUnread).
- N2 (🔴): notifications/sounds dedupe on the event id, not the unread count —
fixes "read a DM, next message never notifies again".
- T4 (🟠): the thread notification path no longer re-gates on the room count, so
an explicit per-thread "All replies" override in a Mentions-only room fires.
- N3 (🟠): getUnreadInfos skips phantom {0,0} entries (muted-thread-only rooms no
longer light the nav row / pollute unread filters).
- N4 (🟠): the Receipt handler recomputes unread instead of blanket-DELETE, so a
threaded receipt can't wipe a room's valid main-timeline badge.
- T2 (🟠): thread "Jump to Latest" re-anchors the virtual window (was landing on
a stale mid/old event).
Gates: tsc/eslint/prettier clean, build OK, 678 tests.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
4 parallel deep-audit agents over the Tier-1 high-risk areas. Findings only (no
source changes). Top 🔴: markThreadAsRead corrupts the main read marker via a
thread-root receipt (a SECOND instance of the P6 read-receipt regression, likely
a live cause of "unread won't clear"); favicon/title count double-counts space
aggregates; deliverNotification dedupe cache never cleared on read → missed
notifications/sounds. Plus 🟠 (thread "All" override defeated, phantom
muted-thread dot, receipt-DELETE badge race, thread jump-to-latest, call
forceState-on-reconnect clobber, AFK wrong-mic auto-mute, stale control observer)
and a long 🟡 tail. Recorded in LOTUS_TODO for prioritized fix passes.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
- index.tsx: request navigator.storage.persist() for logged-in sessions so the
browser can't evict the IndexedDB rust-crypto store (eviction while the
localStorage session survives resurrects the device with a blank store → the
KE-1 "one time key already exists" upload storm). Guarded, checks persisted()
first, best-effort.
- Docs: remove HANDOFF_ELEMENT_CALL_FORK.md, LOTUS_E2EE_INVESTIGATION.md, and
LOTUS_BUGS.md. Port their live content into the three kept docs — verification
backlog → LOTUS_TESTING; open bugs + E2EE (KE-1..4) + an Element Call fork
operational reference (publish steps + io.lotus action catalog) → LOTUS_TODO.
Fix all dangling references (README, code comments, cross-doc links). Full
history of the removed docs remains in git.
Gates: tsc/eslint/prettier clean, build OK, 665 tests.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Add HSTS + Permissions-Policy + the standard X-Frame/X-Content/Referrer set to
the contrib nginx (443 block) and caddy examples; fix the caddy SPA try_files
fallback (stray space). Generic (no homeserver-specific CSP). The real prod
config lives in the matrix repo. P6-4 trimmed to headers only — patch-package /
types-drift / build-config skipped (see LOTUS_TODO).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Forward: checkbox multi-select room picker + "Send to N rooms" batch send
(Promise.allSettled). Full success auto-closes; partial failure keeps the dialog
open with a "Forwarded to X/N — failed: …" summary and prunes the selection to
only the failures (retry won't duplicate to already-sent rooms). Content builder
extracted to a unit-tested forwardContent.ts (edit-forwarding, reply-strip,
undecryptable-refused; 4 tests).
Bookmarks: BookmarksPanel resolves each saved message's live event (useRoomEvent)
so previews reflect edits and show a deleted indicator for redactions; the stored
snapshot stays as the fallback while loading, on fetch failure, or after leaving
the room. Stored bookmark shape unchanged.
Gates: tsc/eslint/prettier clean, build OK, 665 tests. Reviewed (dup-resend on
retry + Checkbox readOnly fixed).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
CallControl now sends the new io.lotus.set_deafen action (join-gated via
forceState) on every deafen / screenshare-audio-mute toggle + on join, ALONGSIDE
the retained iframe-DOM .muted hack (transitional). Against the current pinned
bundle the action is immediately error-replied + swallowed by .catch — inert, no
timeout. Reordered toggleSound() to commit state before setSound() so the sent
deafen value isn't inverted.
Phase 2 (after the fork is published): bump the pin lotus.1 -> lotus.2 and delete
the DOM hack. Docs: HANDOFF §12.4, LOTUS_TODO P6-2, LOTUS_BUGS.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
jaredandClaude Opus 4.8