@mention notifications leak confidential/internal ticket content to users with no access — worse than #46 #69
Closed
opened 2026-09-01 00:07:08 -04:00 by jared
·
1 comment
No Branch/Tag Specified
main
development
fix/comment-markdown-persist-18
deploy-2026.10.03-279
deploy-2026.10.03-275
deploy-2026.09.26-272
deploy-2026.09.25-268
deploy-2026.09.25-264
deploy-2026.09.24-258
deploy-2026.09.24-254
deploy-2026.09.12-242
deploy-2026.09.12-238
deploy-2026.09.12-234
deploy-2026.09.12-230
deploy-2026.09.12-226
deploy-2026.09.12-222
deploy-2026.09.11-218
deploy-2026.09.11-214
deploy-2026.09.11-210
deploy-2026.09.11-206
deploy-2026.09.11-202
deploy-2026.09.11-198
deploy-2026.09.11-194
deploy-2026.09.11-190
deploy-2026.09.11-186
deploy-2026.09.09-182
deploy-2026.09.09-178
deploy-2026.09.08-172
deploy-2026.09.01-163
deploy-2026.08.08-155
deploy-2026.08.08-151
deploy-2026.08.08-147
deploy-2026.08.08-143
deploy-2026.08.08-139
deploy-2026.07.15-130
deploy-2026.07.15-122
deploy-2026.07.11-107
deploy-2026.06.30-96
deploy-2026.06.30-92
deploy-2026.06.30-88
deploy-2026.06.30-84
deploy-2026.06.30-80
deploy-2026.06.30-76
deploy-2026.06.30-72
deploy-2026.06.30-68
deploy-2026.04.29-49
deploy-2026.04.29-41
deploy-2026.04.18-35
deploy-2026.04.16-31
deploy-2026.04.16-27
deploy-2026.04.16-23
deploy-2026.04.16-11
deploy-2026.04.14-9
Labels
Clear labels
api
bug
concurrency
config
data-integrity
dead-code
documentation
duplicate
enhancement
help wanted
invalid
needs-decision
notifications
performance
priority/docs
priority/high
priority/low
priority/medium
question
rate-limiting
reliability
security
ux
wontfix
workflow
Bearer/internal API surface
Something is not working
Race condition / concurrency bug
Configuration / deployment default
Data correctness / schema / integrity issue
Unused / dead code cleanup
README / docs accuracy
This issue or pull request already exists
New feature
Need some help
Something is wrong
Needs a maintainer decision, not clearly a bug
Matrix / in-app notification bug
Performance or resource-usage concern
Documentation-only gap
High-severity / high-impact issue
Low-severity / cosmetic issue
Medium-severity issue
More information is needed
Rate limiting behavior
Reliability / error-handling gap
Security or access-control impact
User-facing UX/functional bug
This won't be fixed
Ticket status workflow engine
Milestone
No items
No Milestone
Projects
Clear projects
No projects
No Assignees
Notifications
Due Date
No due date set.
Dependencies
No dependencies set.
Reference: LotusGuild/tinker_tickets#69
Reference in New Issue
Block a user
Blocking a user prevents them from interacting with repositories, such as opening or commenting on pull requests or issues. Learn more about blocking a user.
Severity: High
helpers/NotificationHelper.php::sendMentionNotification()(~lines 139-154), called fromapi/add_comment.php:185with no visibility check or parameter at all. UnlikesendCommentNotification()/notifyWatchers()(which redact the comment preview for non-public tickets), this function always sends the full 200-char comment preview + ticket title as a Matrix DM directly to the mentioned user.Impact: Commenting
@bob check this outon a confidential ticket Bob has no access to (not creator/assignee/admin, not invisibility_groups) sends Bob a Matrix DM with the ticket's title AND the comment text — de facto visibility into contentcanUserAccessTicket()would otherwise deny him entirely. This is a more severe instance of the pattern in #46 (which only leaks the title to a shared list) since it delivers both title and comment body directly to an individual with zero standing access.Fix: Before sending a mention notification, verify the mentioned user actually has access to the ticket (
canUserAccessTicket()); if not, either skip the notification or send a heavily redacted version (e.g. "You were mentioned on a ticket you don't have access to") with no title/content.Fixed and verified (real webhook payload capture + real MariaDB access-control checks). Merged to main in commit
99a0cf5.